Welcome to Johnny's New York Style Pizza
At Johnny's New York Style Pizza, our story is rooted in a passion for authentic New York flavors right in the heart of Covington, GA. With a diverse menu that ranges from the loaded Deluxe Pizza to the fresh and flavorful Gourmet Pizza, each dish is crafted to satisfy every palate. Our commitment to quality shines through in every bite of our hand-tossed pizzas and gluten-free options. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere, great service, and the ability to enjoy pizza by the slice. Whether you're dining in or taking out, Johnny's offers a delicious slice of New York nostalgia that keeps our patrons coming back for more.
- 10176 Carlin Dr, Covington, GA 30014 Hotline: (678) 342-4343
Welcome to Johnny's New York Style Pizza, where the vibrant flavors of Italy come alive in the heart of Covington, GA. Located at 10176 Carlin Dr, this pizzeria is more than just a restaurant; it's an experience that transports you straight to the bustling streets of New York City with each delectable bite.
At Johnny's, the menu is a treasure trove of authentic Italian cuisine, specializing in mouth-watering pizzas and hearty sandwiches. The star of the show is, of course, their N.Y. Style Pizza. Each pizza is hand-tossed to perfection, loaded with fresh ingredients, and crafted to satisfy any craving. Here are some must-try highlights:
- Veggie Deluxe Pizza: A vibrant combination of onions, green peppers, mushrooms, fresh spinach, diced tomatoes, and both green and black olives - perfect for veggie lovers.
- Johnnys Italian Special Pizza: A house specialty that combines savory sausage, mushrooms, onions, pepperoni, and green peppers for a flavor explosion.
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza: This dish will ignite your taste buds with a kick, featuring chicken strips, red onions, bacon, and a drizzle of hot sauce.
- Build Your Own Pizza: Get creative with a 12" or 16" hand-tossed pizza anyone can craft to their liking.
For those seeking gluten-free options, Johnny's offers a delectable Gluten-Free Crust for their pizzas, ensuring everyone can join in on the fun. Enjoy customizing your 10" pizza with any of their fresh toppings at a starting price of $16.09.
Customers rave about their experience at Johnny's. Many have highlighted the welcoming atmosphere and the attentive service, with one guest praising a staff member named Melody for her exceptional service. The cozy setup, complete with multiple televisions showing various games, creates an inviting ambiance that keeps the excitement alive.
While some have noted that food can take a little longer due to its freshness, patrons agree that it is well worth the wait. The quality and taste of the meals have garnered a loyal following, with many making repeat visits. The ability to order by the slice allows you to sample more of their delicious offerings.
In conclusion, Johnny's New York Style Pizza is a culinary gem that combines quality ingredients, excellent service, and a vibrant atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just passing through Covington, this pizzeria is a must-visit destination for anyone craving a slice of authentic New York-style pizza.
For inquiries, reach out at (678) 342-4343 and prepare to indulge in an unforgettable dining experience!

I came in recently to pick up a to go order and there was a customer being very demeaning and condescending towards the to-go orders worker, shout out to her for having excellent composure bc that man was very rude and passive.

I have been twice food was consistently good both visits. Melody is a wonderful waitress and does her job well. I enjoy the multiple televisions with different games on each. Plenty of seating and definitely a lot of repeat regular customers. Very comfortable setting and not too loud, and not too quiet either. Only complaint right now is food a little slow getting out, but hey, it's made fresh. I'm a be a repeat customer as long as food stays consistent and Melody is there.

Great food. Good prices. Wonderful staff. It's an all around pleasant dining experience.

Very good. And soooo much better than the Conyers location. Honestly I don't see how they are both Johnny's. The Covington location is bigger, has a sit down restaurant, TVs & a bar. Pizza was very good too

Best part is that you can order by the slice!! It's a little pricey lol but sometimes you have to live a little. Overall the pizza is really good and the service is fast. I have been a couple of their locations and this one is probably one of the better locations. The waitress was very friendly and made me feel welcomed. I would go again based on the service alone. The pizza is good though but you need to eat it hot!